Village of Little Chute v. John D. Bunnell, 2012AP1266, District 3, 11/14/12 court of appeals decision (1-judge, ineligible for publication); case activity Officer’s failure to perform FSTs pursuant to established protocols (HGN test requires 4-second pass-of-the-eye, and officer used 2-second pass), “compromises the validity of the test results,” and therefore “cannot be used to support a determination of probable cause to arrest,” ¶19… Read more
4. Procedure
State v. William R. Hartman, 2011AP622, District 4, 9/20/12 court of appeals decision (1-judge, ineligible for publication); case activity OWI – Refusal Hearing – Raising Challenge to Lawfulness of Stop Refusal hearing supports litigation of lawfulness of stop; State v. Anagnos, 2012 WI 64, ¶42, 341 Wis. 2d 576, 815 N.W.2d 675, followed: ¶14 Accordingly, we reject the State’s… Read more
State v. Dimitrius Anagnos, 2012 WI 64, reversing 2011 WI App 118; case activity OWI – Refusal Hearing – Authority to Litigate Constitutionality of Traffic Stop Constitutionality of the traffic stop may be raised as a defense at a refusal hearing, § 343.305(9)(a)5.a. ¶29 In this case, the relevant portion of the statute is found in sub. (9)(a)5.a. That subsection… Read more
Village of Elm Grove v. Richard K. Brefka, 2011AP2888, District 1/2, 6/19/12, WSC review granted 11/14/12 court of appeals decision (1-judge, ineligible for publication), supreme court review granted 11/14/12; case activity The municipal court lacks competence to extend the 10-day time deadline for requesting a refusal hearings, given the clear language of §§ 343.305(9)(a)4. and (10)(a). Village of… Read more
on review of published opinion; for Anagnos: Barry S. Cohen; case activity; prior post Traffic Stop – Reasonable Suspicion – OWI Refusal Hearing Challenge to Arrest Issues (composed by On Point): 1. Whether the officer could lawfully stop Anagnos’ vehicle for failing to use a turn signal where neither traffic nor pedestrians were present, § 346.34(1)(b). 2. Whether the officer… Read more
State v. Darren A. Kliss, 2007 WI App 13 For Kliss: Michael C. Witt Issue/Holding: ¶7 … Because the implied consent law makes no provision for the right to counsel, an officer is correct to record a refusal if the arrestee insists on speaking to an attorney before answering.…¶8 … County of Ozaukee v. Quelle, 198… Read more
State v. Darren A. Kliss, 2007 WI App 13 For Kliss: Michael C. Witt Issue/Holding: Administering Miranda rights prior to the “Informing the Accused” caution applicable to OWI does not invalidate the latter (at least where the motorist is concurrently under arrest for a separate crime): ¶14 There is no dispute that Thomas read Kliss the Miranda warning… Read more
State v. Patrick J. Fahey, 2005 WI App 171 Issue: Whether requested alternative testing at agency expense is deemed a “request” within § 343.305(5)(a) where made after driver was released from custody, left police department, and then returned about 15 minutes later, ¶7. Holding: ¶14 … The State, in keeping with the circuit court’s decision, argues… Read more
